How to check a faulty Temperature Sensor?
Sometimes sensors can break or degrade in harsh environments. You might be suffering from intermittent thermocouple failure or instruments might be showing “Open Circuit”. Therefore, to help you to check a sensor, we created a guide to check issues with thermocouples (TCs) and resistance thermometers (RTDs) to diagnose various failure modes to help you rectify the situation.
What causes temperature sensor to fail?
Temperature sensors can fail due to various reasons, including:-
• Environmental factors: Exposure to extreme temperatures, humidity, corrosive chemicals, or physical damage can degrade the sensor’s components over time, leading to failure.
• Mechanical stress: Excessive mechanical stress or vibration can damage the sensor’s delicate components or connections, causing it to malfunction.
• Electrical overload: Overvoltage or electrical surges can damage the sensor’s internal circuitry, leading to failure.
• Wear and tear: Like any electronic component, temperature sensors can degrade over time with normal use, leading to decreased accuracy or failure.
• Contamination: Accumulation of dirt, dust, or other contaminants on the sensor’s surface can interfere with its operation and cause inaccurate readings or failure.
Calibration issues:-
* Improper calibration or drift over time can lead to inaccurate temperature measurements, affecting the sensor’s performance.
• Manufacturing defects: Defects in the sensor’s manufacturing process, such as poor soldering or faulty components, can cause premature failure.Regular maintenance, proper installation, and adherence to environmental specifications can help mitigate these factors and prolong the lifespan of temperature sensors.
Symptoms of bad temperature sensor:-
Symptoms of a Faulty Thermocouple:
1. Erratic Readings
• Sudden jumps or drops in temperature readings.
• Fluctuating readings that do not correspond to actual temperature changes.
2. Open Circuit:-
• Display shows a very high or infinite temperature.
• The measuring instrument may indicate an open circuit or error code.
3. Short Circuit:-
• Display shows a very low or negative temperature.
• Consistently low readings regardless of actual temperature changes.
4. Drift:-
• Gradual deviation of readings over time from the actual temperature.
5. Noise or Interference:
• Readings affected by electrical noise or electromagnetic interference.
6. Physical Damage:
• Visible wear, corrosion, or breaks in the thermocouple wires.
• Damage to the insulation or protective sheath.
Symptoms of a Faulty RTD:
1. Erratic Readings:-
• Sudden, unpredictable changes in temperature readings.
• Unstable readings that do not match the environment’s temperature.
2. Open Circuit:-
• Display shows an out-of-range high temperature or error code.
• Measuring device may indicate an open circuit error.
3. Short Circuit:-
• Display shows an out-of-range low temperature or error code.
• Consistently low or incorrect readings.
4. Drift:-
• Slow, steady changes in readings that deviate from the actual temperature over time.
5. Poor Linearity:-
• Non-linear response, especially if the RTD is damaged or has degraded over time.
6. Self-Heating:-
• Incorrect readings due to the RTD heating itself if excessive current is passed through it.
7. Physical Damage:
• Visible damage to the RTD element or wires.
• Damage to the protective sheath or housing.
Steps for troubleshooting a faulty temperature sensor:
1. Check -ve and +ve leads are correct.
2. Check you are using the correct type of cable.
3. Check for local heat sources affecting your readings.
4. Check setup of your temperature controller/readout.
5. Resolve out of range errors.
6. Resolve Sensor Break/Open circuit errors.
7. Physically inspect sensor for damage.
8. Check temperature transmitter.
9. Test faulty thermocouple (TC) with a multimeter, check millivolt at its terminals and check corresponding temperature in the “Millivolt Vs Temperature Table”.
10.Test faulty resistance thermometer (RTD) with a multimeter and check the corresponding temperature for the actual resistance in the “Resistance Vs Temperature Table”.
11.Check RTD sensor wire with grounding and make sure wire are not grounding. Like compressor skin type RTD.
How to test a faulty thermocouple or resistance thermometer?
The first indication that a thermocouple or pt-100 sensor is not working correctly will be from the instrument it is connected to.
The readings might appear lower or higher than expected or the instrument will be showing an error code.
Instruments connected to a thermocouple or pt-100 will often be a temperature controller or a readout.
Different errors on a controller will mean different things depending on the brand and model.
Check your temperature controller manual to make sure it isn’t an error with the controller itself.
Check if the -ve and +ve leads swapped!If your temperature sensor is a resistance thermometer (RTD), swapping the -ve and +ve leads will not influence the reading. Thermocouple readings do change if leads are not correctly connected.
If -ve and +ve leads are swapped between a thermocouple (TC) and an instrument then the reading will change relative to the ambient temperature e.g., a reading of 100°C with an ambient temperature of 25°C will read as 75°C, if the leads are not correctly connected.
Ensure that the -ve thermocouple lead and +ve thermocouple lead are wired correctly to your instrument.
Check for any thermocouple cable wiring issues!
Incorrectly wired compensating cable
Incorrect wiring of thermocouple cables can be further complicated because thermocouples often use compensating cable.
It is possible that the compensating cable is incorrectly wired to the thermocouple. It may appear correctly wired at the instrument but not correct between the thermocouple and compensating cable.
To avoid this, make sure -ve and +ve legs match correctly along the full length of the thermocouple, to the compensating cable, to the instrument.Using the wrong compensating typeEach compensating cable is also tied to a specific thermocouple type.
To ensure accuracy you must only use compensating cable of the same type e.g., a type K thermocouple could only be extended with type k compensating cable. Sometimes other types of cable such as general instrument cable, or copper cable is used to extend thermocouples, and this also creates errors.Using compensating cable in high-temperature environments
The final quirk with compensating cable is that it should not be used in high temperature environments. Thermocouple compensating cable is rated for a lower temperature than thermocouple cable. Try to use compensating cable in ambient temperatures to reduce errors.Check for local heat source issues!If your thermocouple is reading high, it could be because your sensor is located too close to a heat source.
If your sensor is near a local heat source, it could increase the temperature being measured as opposed to the position you wish to measure temperature.Check temperature transmitter settings!If your sensor is using a temperature transmitter it is important to check that the output of the transmitter and the input of the instrument is the same. Most commonly a signal range of 4…20 mA is used.Check temperature controller settings!
Check input settings on temperature controller!
For example, if you have your temperature controller setup for Type S input but attach a Type B thermocouple sensor it would display an incorrect temperature and lead you to believe your sensor was faulty.
You will need to make sure the input selected on the controller matches the type of thermocouple or resistance thermometer connected to it.There are also a couple of controller errors that point to a fault in the temperature sensor.
Instrument shows: Input signal higher or lower than limit (Out of range error)The controller could be displaying several things indicating that it believes there is an out-of-range error.
Each brand and model of controller is different so look in your temperature controller manual to find out how an out-of-range error will show on your specific model. If you have an out-of-range error the input the temperature sensor is providing is out of the expected range according to the configured input on the controller.
For example, if you had your controller setup for Type S thermocouple input it would expect a small range of mV.
If you then connected a Type E thermocouple, a thermocouple with a much higher mV range, at 300°C it would show an out-of-range error.
Instrument shows: –
Sensor Break Error (Open Circuit)If the controller shows an open circuit error the connection to the sensor is not complete. This could mean either one of the sensor terminals is not connected to the controller or there is a break somewhere in the sensor. Each brand and model of controller is different so look in your temperature controller manual to find out how a sensor break error will show on your specific model. If you have checked that the sensor is properly connected to the controller, and you still get an open circuit error you will need to disconnect the sensor and remove it from your process to further test the broken thermocouple or broken thermometer for faults.
Conduct a visual check of the temperature sensor!
After removing the sensors from your process, visually check for damage along the length of the sheath and at the measuring point. On a thermocouple you will have a measuring junction at the tip, on a resistance thermometer you will have an element at the tip e.g., a pt100 element.
If there are any breaks along the sheath or the tip of the sensor is broken it will probably be the cause of the fault. If visually nothing appears to be wrong, you can verify any internal breaks with a multimeter.
Troubleshooting temperature sensors with a multimeter In-head thermocouple multimeter check One check you can carry out with a thermocouple is if you short the +ve and -ve wires in a terminal connection head, if the instrument and any compensating cables are setup correctly the instrument will give an ambient reading.Testing a faulty thermocouple with a multimeter
Get your faulty thermocouple and a multimeter. Change your multimeter to Continuity beeper/diode symbol/flow of current. Some multimeters will beep if there is a break in the circuit, some multimeters will beep when the circuit is complete. Know how your multimeter functions.
Two multimeters showing the diode/continuity beeper setting selected:- Attach each leg of the thermocouple to the multimeter. It doesn’t matter which way the positive and negative leg are. After connecting the thermocouple to the multimeter, a working thermocouple will produce a beep (or no beep if your multimeter works the opposite way). The screen will display resistance in Ohms, which could be zero. If there is a break it will display OL or similar. If you are experiencing intermittent thermocouple failure you can adjust the position of the sensor and its leads to see if you can trigger the fault.Testing a faulty resistance thermometer (RTD) with a multimeterIn this section, we will explain how to test RTD with a multimeter. So, after removing the faulty resistance thermometer, get your multimeter and change it to the Ohms setting (Ω).
Two multimeters showing the ohms (Ω) setting selected-
:Next connect the resistance thermometer to your multimeter. It doesn’t matter which way around the positive and negative legs are. Some resistance thermometers have 3 or 4 wires. Make sure you connect the wires of a similar color together. e.g., White, and white connect to one terminal and red and red connect to the other terminal.Four wire resistance thermometer connected to multimeter clips. Showing white-white and red-red leads connected together:If your resistance thermometer is connected to the multimeter and it is reading OL there is a possible break in the sensor. You can move any flexible cable or tails around to try and trigger any intermittent faults. In a working resistance thermometer, the multimeter would read a value in ohms, an example table is below:
Ohms reading at Room Temperature (20-25°C) Resistance Thermometer Type (RTD)107.793-109.735Ω Pt100538.967-548.673 Ω Pt5001077.935-1097.347Ω Pt1000~0Ω
Broken sensor or not a resistance thermometer
Tolerance to these values would depend on the accuracy of your resistance thermometer and the actual temperature in your room.Sample resistance thermometer reading 109.7 ohms which is around 25°C